Investment Read Time: 9 min

All That Matters: The State of Play

The midterms are behind us, markets have been bumpy, and everyone wants to know what comes next for the AI trade. In this episode of All That Matters, Mike and Ross explain why the market dislikes surprises more than uncertainty, whether the AI trade is dead or simply changing, and why a broader market could be a good thing for investors.

Midterms Recap

Ross: Welcome to All That Matters. We’re recording in mid-November. We just had a midterm election, and we’ve had a lot of market volatility around it. Rather than doing something big-picture or thematic, we thought we’d do an episode on the state of play as we see it heading into the end of the year and setting up 2027. Let’s start with the election and then transition into what it means for the market from our view.

Mike: Ross and I spend a lot of time on the road talking to our clients and financial advisors about what’s happening in the world. We’re at a critical juncture. We just had an election, and everybody is wondering what’s happening with the AI trade. So let’s catch everybody up. You’ll commonly hear that the market hates uncertainty, but that’s actually not true. The market is always dealing with uncertainty; we’ve never had certainty in the history of the world. What the market actually hates is surprises. The market doesn’t like something coming out of nowhere that causes investors to say, “What now?” Think about 9/11 or COVID. Those were total surprises. Was the election a surprise to the stock market? I would argue yes and no. Prediction markets were already predicting that Democrats would take the Senate and House before the election. The surprise was how much they took both chambers. A Senate seat in Mississippi went blue. A Senate seat in Kansas went blue for the first time since the 1930s. That’s the surprise. So what is the market doing now? It’s asking, “What are the new rules of the road? How will this impact the economy and the AI trade?” Remember, this wasn’t a massive surprise because Democrats won. It was a surprise because of the sheer size of the shift in power. In the last 11 elections, we’ve been shifting power back and forth. That isn’t anything new.

 

The AI Trade

Mike: What we want to focus on is the AI trade because that’s what has been driving everything. When a Democratic shift happens, we ask: Are there going to be more rules and regulations? Are they going to slow down data centers? If they slow down data centers, does that slow down chips? Elections are about social changes, judges and all sorts of things. But what we really want to focus on is: Are companies still building products and creating solutions? The answer is yes.

Ross: To your point about uncertainty versus surprise, the AI trade peaked over the summer. There have been some fits and starts, but there has been a lot of weakness in semiconductor names, particularly the overseas names linked to the AI trade. You could argue that was the market starting to price in the potential for a Democratic sweep. The surprise you talked about leads to a day like we saw last week, when the market was off 4% or 5% as everyone rushed to figure out what this means in real time. The semiconductors have been as much as roughly 20% of the S&P 500. We have this extremely concentrated market, and it’s concentrated in the one thing people have wanted to talk about for most of this bull market: AI. Now we have to figure out the new state of play. Semiconductors are down about 30% from their high. The nice thing is the resilience of other sectors has helped cushion that. The consumer has bounced back. Industrials have done okay, as have some of the more defensive names. We undoubtedly have some churn in the market, and I think the big question we have to ask is: Is the AI trade dead, or is it just changing?

Mike: That’s the question everyone is focusing on. Because if it is, that would be a headwind for the stock market. Every now and then the market focuses on one thing, and for a while it’s been AI. It’s a lot like focusing on your team’s quarterback. Take the Packers. We love to talk about Jordan Love. Is he good? Is he bad? Is it all Jordan Love? You talk about this one thing for the longest time. But then a receiver gets hurt, an offensive lineman gets hurt or a running back doesn’t perform as well. Suddenly you start talking about lots of things and the waters get muddied. What do I need to know about the Packers? That’s what happened with the election. We’re muddying the waters now. Are data centers going to slow down? Will that mean chips slow down? What about the Fed? Are they going to hike? We start talking about a lot of different things. I’m going to give the rose-colored-glasses view here. If we’re only focused on one thing, AI, and we do that for a long time, that becomes a bubble because one thing just keeps going higher. If you find a way to slowly talk about other things, and an election is the impetus for that, you spread out attention. Now maybe housing is something to talk about. Does Democratic control mean anything for housing? What about real estate? What about materials? The election might change the way we talk about the market, and that could be a good thing. Maybe we’re slowing down the AI trade, which allows it to go longer. That is something we would want to see because we don’t want the semiconductor sector to be the entire S&P 500.

Ross: I think you’re right. We’ve been wondering what is going to slow all the AI spending. Is it going to become a bubble? Without an impediment, it probably would have been. Maybe this offers a way for that to happen. AI is fascinating, fun and a crazy technology, but there’s a lot more out there for investors. Diversification is important for people to think about here. One example I like to use around elections is how traditional energy versus renewable energy has performed under different administrations. They’ve done the exact opposite of what you might expect. Under a Republican administration, renewable energy significantly outperformed. Under a Democratic administration, traditional energy significantly outperformed. Why? Because the U.S. economy and the global economy are so much more complex and interconnected than just who’s in the White House or who controls Congress at a given time. Politicians matter. Elections matter. But the economy is so big, complex and interconnected that you want to press pause before extrapolating the first opinion or the first market reaction over the next year or four years. Maybe this is a positive thing for AI. That’s not what most investors were saying the day after the election, right? Time will tell. We’ll be here along the way.

 

What We're Thankful For

Ross: You and I spend so much time talking about politics during election years. So let’s move on and stick with your rose-colored-glasses view. We’re approaching the holidays. What are you thankful for, Mike?

Mike: There’s a lot to be thankful for. I look at Wisconsin over the past month or so with the Brewers and the World Series run we went on. It showcased how great Milwaukee is as a city and how great our fans are. Sometimes Milwaukee can get lost in the mix with some of the other big cities, but we had a great run. The weather’s been great. It’s just been a fantastic fall in Wisconsin, and I’m really thankful for that. I’m also thankful for how the market is evolving. I’m thankful that we’re creating this technology that I think really will change the world in dramatic ways, and I’m thankful that our clients get to benefit from those companies creating new products and driving the stock market. All of these things work together. I think the world is in an interesting place right now. It may not seem like it. Maybe you didn’t agree with the election. Maybe you did. Maybe you think the world’s a crazy place. But the stock market has been doing well for years. We’re building this new technology. Yes, the world is a chaotic place, but you have to sometimes look around and say, “The Brewers are winning. Milwaukee is great. We’re about to sit down to turkey and stuffing.” Ross, I’m thankful for a lot. How about you?

Ross: Me too. Both you and I have been on the road a lot this year, and we’ve been using America’s 250th birthday to talk to clients about why the stock market has done so well and about all the wealth creation that stems from our unique American brand of capitalism. I was thinking about it this week. We’re going to have this Anthropic IPO, a big AI company. Regardless of what you think about the company or AI in general, I find it miraculous that a company that was literally started five years ago in 2021, worth zero, is now going to be worth at least a trillion dollars and probably more. We have a system that fosters that growth, enables that and allows people like us to participate, to buy stocks and be part owners of these companies. It’s incredible. I’m thankful for that too. And I’m thankful for this show and the partnership here, Mike. Thanks, everybody.

This information has been developed by a member of Baird Wealth Solutions Group, a team of wealth management specialists who provide support to Baird Financial Advisor teams. The information offered is provided to you for informational purposes only. Robert W. Baird & Co. Incorporated is not a legal or tax services provider, and you are strongly encouraged to seek the advice of the appropriate professional advisors before taking any action. The information reflected on this page is Baird expert opinion today and is subject to change. The information provided here has not taken into consideration the investment goals or needs of any specific investor, and investors should not make any investment decisions based solely on this information. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. All investments have some level of risk, and investors have different time horizons, goals and risk tolerances, so speak to your Baird Financial Advisor before taking action.

Have A Question About This Topic?

Thank you! Oops!

Related Content

Diversification, Patience, and Consistency

Diversification, Patience, and Consistency

Three important factors when it comes to your financial life.

All That Matters: Weathering a Storm

All That Matters: Weathering a Storm

Mike and Ross discuss how to navigate market storms while keeping your long-term financial goals in focus.

Five Do's and Don'ts of Medical Debt

Five Do's and Don'ts of Medical Debt

1 in 5 Americans say they struggle to keep up with their medical expenses – luckily, there may be more options than it seems.